37000 Feet | Browse and search NASA's Aviation Safety Reporting System |
|
Attributes | |
ACN | 1044916 |
Time | |
Date | 201210 |
Local Time Of Day | 1201-1800 |
Place | |
Locale Reference | ZZZ.ARTCC |
State Reference | US |
Environment | |
Flight Conditions | VMC |
Light | Daylight |
Aircraft 1 | |
Make Model Name | B737-300 |
Operating Under FAR Part | Part 121 |
Flight Phase | Cruise |
Flight Plan | IFR |
Component | |
Aircraft Component | Fuel System |
Person 1 | |
Function | Captain Pilot Not Flying |
Experience | Flight Crew Last 90 Days 207 Flight Crew Type 15000 |
Person 2 | |
Function | Pilot Flying First Officer |
Events | |
Anomaly | Aircraft Equipment Problem Critical Inflight Event / Encounter Fuel Issue |
Narrative:
We were enroute at FL350. I decided to burn the last bit of remaining fuel (approximately 300 pounds) in the center tank. I announced this to the first officer and said I would use the crossfeed procedure (open the crossfeed and turn on one center pump). Several minutes went by and the first officer said the center tank was empty. I noticed a slight imbalance of about 300 pounds so I turned the center tank pump switch off and left the crossfeed open. Then; I turned off the low side pump (#1 engine) to balance and announced this as well to the first officer. He acknowledged. Several more minutes went by when I noticed the #1 engine instruments start to roll back. As the airplane started to roll left; the first officer got on the controls and corrected the flight path. I called center and told the controller our engine had rolled back and we needed an immediate descent. We were given clearance to descend (we were descending anyway). While descending; I turned the #1 engine fuel pumps back on and closed the crossfeed valve. All bright/dim sequences seemed to be working properly. I told the first officer to take the comm 1 radio and keep flying the plane while I looked for a place to land. On the fix page; we were only 50 miles from a major airport so I told the first officer that's where we were headed. The 'a' flight attendant called to say the cabin lights went out. I explained that our left engine had rolled back and as soon as I could start the APU; the lights should come back. We were still descending and low enough to start the APU; so I did. While the first officer was coordinating our divert with ATC; I got on the passenger address system and told our customers what had happened. According to the flight attendants; it was in no way alarming; but reassuring. I explained the need to land as soon as we could; but that once we did land; we would simply taxi back to the gate and go from there. Still descending; we decided to run the engine failure/shutdown checklist as throttle movement was unresponsive on the #1 engine. When the engine was shut down; I noticed all engine instruments were indicating the same as when it had rolled back: not frozen; but windmilling. I called the divert airport operations to let them know we were coming in and for them to please call dispatch. We were being vectored by approach and wanted to see if we could restart the #1 engine because it met all the parameters. We ran the in-flight engine start and got our engine back. We also ran the descent checklist and told approach we were ready. We got cleared for the visual and landed and taxied without incident. I made an entry in the maintenance log and called dispatch. We just happened to have one of our mechanics on board. He stated that boeing might come out with something on high altitude cross-feeding or simply not crossfeed unless there was a serious imbalance. Speaking to my chief pilots after the incident; they also recommended not crossfeeding at high altitude. I don't normally crossfeed with such a small imbalance and; after this incident; I never will. Can we recommend the same advice to other crews? There is nothing in our books that tells us not to; but look what could happen.
Original NASA ASRS Text
Title: A B737-300 engine shutdown from fuel starvation at FL350 while the engine was being cross fed with the high tank pumps ON and the crossfeed valve open. The flight diverted to a nearby airport and the engine was restarted prior to landing.
Narrative: We were enroute at FL350. I decided to burn the last bit of remaining fuel (approximately 300 LBS) in the center tank. I announced this to the First Officer and said I would use the crossfeed procedure (open the crossfeed and turn on one center pump). Several minutes went by and the First Officer said the center tank was empty. I noticed a slight imbalance of about 300 pounds so I turned the center tank pump switch off and left the crossfeed open. Then; I turned off the low side pump (#1 engine) to balance and announced this as well to the First Officer. He acknowledged. Several more minutes went by when I noticed the #1 engine instruments start to roll back. As the airplane started to roll left; the First Officer got on the controls and corrected the flight path. I called Center and told the Controller our engine had rolled back and we needed an immediate descent. We were given clearance to descend (we were descending anyway). While descending; I turned the #1 engine fuel pumps back on and closed the crossfeed valve. All bright/dim sequences seemed to be working properly. I told the First Officer to take the COMM 1 radio and keep flying the plane while I looked for a place to land. On the Fix page; we were only 50 miles from a major airport so I told the First Officer that's where we were headed. The 'A' Flight Attendant called to say the cabin lights went out. I explained that our left engine had rolled back and as soon as I could start the APU; the lights should come back. We were still descending and low enough to start the APU; so I did. While the First Officer was coordinating our divert with ATC; I got on the Passenger Address System and told our customers what had happened. According to the flight attendants; it was in no way alarming; but reassuring. I explained the need to land as soon as we could; but that once we did land; we would simply taxi back to the gate and go from there. Still descending; we decided to run the Engine Failure/Shutdown Checklist as throttle movement was unresponsive on the #1 engine. When the engine was shut down; I noticed all engine instruments were indicating the same as when it had rolled back: not frozen; but windmilling. I called the divert airport Operations to let them know we were coming in and for them to please call Dispatch. We were being vectored by Approach and wanted to see if we could restart the #1 engine because it met all the parameters. We ran the In-flight Engine Start and got our engine back. We also ran the Descent Checklist and told Approach we were ready. We got cleared for the visual and landed and taxied without incident. I made an entry in the Maintenance log and called Dispatch. We just happened to have one of our Mechanics on board. He stated that Boeing might come out with something on high altitude cross-feeding or simply not crossfeed unless there was a serious imbalance. Speaking to my Chief Pilots after the incident; they also recommended not crossfeeding at high altitude. I don't normally crossfeed with such a small imbalance and; after this incident; I never will. Can we recommend the same advice to other Crews? There is nothing in our books that tells us not to; but look what could happen.
Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site as of July 2013 and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.