Narrative:

While in cruise enroute; a sudden vibration in the airplane became quite severe in the left engine nacelle. This was quickly followed by a hole in the outboard cowling of left engine. The engine still producing power was shut down in the usual way; feathered; and fuel cut off. The propeller feathered as it should. ATC was immediately notified. I am not sure at that point that I used the word emergency; I know I didn't say mayday. I was unable to hold my assigned altitude at that point. Advising ATC of my situation; I asked for location of nearest airport. The controller was most helpful in advising me in bearing and distance to a nearby airport. I turned in that direction and continued to control the airplane in the usual single-engine fashion. I was in radar contact throughout this; I just don't know if I actually declared an emergency. I know I was dealing with a very urgent situation. The controller asked regarding number of souls and fuel on board.the flight continued to circle over the airport as I lost altitude under control and landed. I talked with the controller until switching over to advisory frequency. He was throughout the ordeal most helpful; courteous; and professional. After landing I contacted flight service on a land line and asked them to relay my safe arrival to center. There were no physical injuries to myself or my wife.upon landing; I taxied to the ramp and shut down the other engine. Exiting the airplane I found the right tire flat. I had not realized that on taxiing; I suspect due to the unusual yaw and drag from the asymmetric thrust of the right engine.at that point; the plane was found to be otherwise undamaged except for the damaged cowling over the left engine which had two holes in it. The lower outboard hole was 8 inches long. Removal of the cowling revealed that the number 4 cylinder head had completely separated from the crankcase at the junction of the cylinder barrel and the flange. The piston was completely destroyed and the connecting rod was badly distorted. Oil was streaked down the outboard edge of the cowling.I think any deviation from assigned altitudes and headings were necessary to deal with an emergency situation; but I am filing this also as I am quite concerned as to what could have caused such a catastrophic failure of a cylinder head in cruise flight. I wouldn't want anyone else to have this kind of 'stress' if it could be avoided. The engine only had approximately 250 hrs on the heads.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: A PA-39 engine with 250 hours on the heads suffered a catastrophic cylinder failure when one separated from the crankcase in flight. An emergency was declared; the engine shutdown and a safe landing followed at a nearby airport.

Narrative: While in cruise enroute; a sudden vibration in the airplane became quite severe in the left engine nacelle. This was quickly followed by a hole in the outboard cowling of left engine. The engine still producing power was shut down in the usual way; feathered; and fuel cut off. The propeller feathered as it should. ATC was immediately notified. I am not sure at that point that I used the word emergency; I know I didn't say Mayday. I was unable to hold my assigned altitude at that point. Advising ATC of my situation; I asked for location of nearest airport. The controller was most helpful in advising me in bearing and distance to a nearby airport. I turned in that direction and continued to control the airplane in the usual single-engine fashion. I was in radar contact throughout this; I just don't know if I actually declared an emergency. I know I was dealing with a very urgent situation. The controller asked regarding number of souls and fuel on board.The flight continued to circle over the airport as I lost altitude under control and landed. I talked with the controller until switching over to advisory frequency. He was throughout the ordeal most helpful; courteous; and professional. After landing I contacted flight service on a land line and asked them to relay my safe arrival to Center. There were no physical injuries to myself or my wife.Upon landing; I taxied to the ramp and shut down the other engine. Exiting the airplane I found the right tire flat. I had not realized that on taxiing; I suspect due to the unusual yaw and drag from the asymmetric thrust of the right engine.At that point; the plane was found to be otherwise undamaged except for the damaged cowling over the left engine which had two holes in it. The lower outboard hole was 8 inches long. Removal of the cowling revealed that the Number 4 cylinder head had completely separated from the crankcase at the junction of the cylinder barrel and the flange. The piston was completely destroyed and the connecting rod was badly distorted. Oil was streaked down the outboard edge of the cowling.I think any deviation from assigned altitudes and headings were necessary to deal with an emergency situation; but I am filing this also as I am quite concerned as to what could have caused such a catastrophic failure of a cylinder head in cruise flight. I wouldn't want anyone else to have this kind of 'stress' if it could be avoided. The engine only had approximately 250 hrs on the heads.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.