Narrative:

During IMC/IFR climb to 4000 ft; selected the left fuel tank. My routine procedure is to have the fuel selector match the minute hand: left tank on the :45min; right fuel tank on the :15min; switching tanks 2x every hour to keep fuel balanced. To switch tanks; I select fuel pump on; switch tanks; verify fuel pressure; select fuel pump off. At xa:45; I thought I selected the left tank. Apparently; I moved the selector beyond left and selected off. At xa:49; the engine sputtered; then stopped. I called ATC; requested immediate turn back to ZZZ; established glide and began the emergency checklist: mixture rich; pump on; switch tanks. The engine started back up. Once confirmed running - I realized my error. I requested to continue on to my destination. Once on the ground; I verified that the stop on the fuel selector did not prevent an inadvertent off selection. Corrective action: visually verify tank selection. Have fuel selector repaired to ensure the tab preventing inadvertent off functions as intended.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: The pilot of a Piper Arrow inadvertently rotated the fuel selector valve beyond the intended position which resulted in fuel starvation. The pilot was able to reposition the valve and resupply fuel to the engine.

Narrative: During IMC/IFR Climb to 4000 ft; selected the left fuel tank. My routine procedure is to have the fuel selector match the minute hand: left tank on the :45min; right fuel tank on the :15min; switching tanks 2x every hour to keep fuel balanced. To switch tanks; I select fuel pump on; switch tanks; verify fuel pressure; select fuel pump off. At XA:45; I thought I selected the left tank. Apparently; I moved the selector beyond LEFT and selected OFF. At XA:49; the engine sputtered; then stopped. I called ATC; requested immediate turn back to ZZZ; established glide and began the emergency checklist: mixture rich; pump on; switch tanks. The engine started back up. Once confirmed running - I realized my error. I requested to continue on to my destination. Once on the ground; I verified that the stop on the fuel selector did not prevent an inadvertent off selection. Corrective action: visually verify tank selection. Have fuel selector repaired to ensure the tab preventing inadvertent off functions as intended.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.