Narrative:

During getting clearance we were given a waypoint; extol; which sounds very familiar to a close by waypoint exall. Waypoint was not originally on flight plan; and after finding what I thought was the correct waypoint I read [back] my clearance with exall. Both points sound familiar; I don't believe anyone noticed. During cruise we started making a turn to exall; when ATC inquired what fix we were going to. We verified the spelling and were informed to proceed to extol.flight path was corrected very quickly after initial diversion; and no further flight interruptions happened. Reading back exact spellings of every fix. Extol and exall are in proximity and sound familiar. Although exall wasn't as good of a route as extol; it wasn't unusual enough to raise suspicion.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: Light Jet First Officer reported of confusion and questioning by Toronto ATC about their heading. Pilot programmed EXALL rather than EXTOL which led to a heading deviation.

Narrative: During getting clearance we were given a waypoint; EXTOL; which sounds very familiar to a close by waypoint EXALL. Waypoint was not originally on flight plan; and after finding what I thought was the correct waypoint I read [back] my clearance with EXALL. Both points sound familiar; I don't believe anyone noticed. During cruise we started making a turn to EXALL; when ATC inquired what fix we were going to. We verified the spelling and were informed to proceed to EXTOL.Flight path was corrected very quickly after initial diversion; and no further flight interruptions happened. Reading back exact spellings of every fix. EXTOL AND EXALL are in proximity and sound familiar. Although EXALL wasn't as good of a route as EXTOL; it wasn't unusual enough to raise suspicion.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.