Narrative:

We were cleared for ILS runway 12 at opf. I was PIC and pm (pilot monitoring) from right seat. Second pilot was PF (pilot flying) from left seat.the following sequence of events occurred:at 2;000 ft. On the approach; opf tower instructed us to climb to 2;500 ft. For traffic. PF initiated a climb. As we began climbing; TCAS issues a resolution advisory (RA) to descend. PF began to lower the nose; as pm notified opf tower that we received the RA. TCAS system changed its indication to command a climb. At the same time; pm acquired the traffic visually and notified PF that traffic was in sight. Traffic passed us on right side with about X mile separation. PF continued approach to normal landing.it would be very useful for ATC to receive live broadcast of TA RA from aircraft; so that controller can avoid issuing instructions that are contrary to TA RA.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: Lear 60 Captain reported receiving an RA on approach that was contrary to ATC instructions.

Narrative: We were cleared for ILS Runway 12 at OPF. I was PIC and PM (Pilot Monitoring) from right seat. Second pilot was PF (Pilot Flying) from left seat.The following sequence of events occurred:At 2;000 ft. on the approach; OPF tower instructed us to climb to 2;500 ft. for traffic. PF initiated a climb. As we began climbing; TCAS issues a Resolution Advisory (RA) to descend. PF began to lower the nose; as PM notified OPF Tower that we received the RA. TCAS system changed its indication to command a climb. At the same time; PM acquired the traffic visually and notified PF that traffic was in sight. Traffic passed us on right side with about X mile separation. PF continued approach to normal landing.It would be very useful for ATC to receive live broadcast of TA RA from aircraft; so that controller can avoid issuing instructions that are contrary to TA RA.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.