37000 Feet | Browse and search NASA's Aviation Safety Reporting System |
|
Attributes | |
ACN | 814461 |
Time | |
Date | 200811 |
Local Time Of Day | 1801 To 2400 |
Place | |
Locale Reference | airport : fll.airport |
State Reference | FL |
Altitude | agl single value : 0 |
Person 1 | |
Affiliation | other |
Function | other personnel |
ASRS Report | 814461 |
Person 2 | |
Affiliation | government : faa |
Function | controller : ground |
Events | |
Anomaly | non adherence : clearance |
Independent Detector | other controllera |
Resolutory Action | controller : issued alert none taken : detected after the fact |
Supplementary | |
Problem Areas | Airport Company |
Primary Problem | Ambiguous |
Narrative:
I was on duty as ramp 1; and received a call on the company cell phone from the fll tower of possible debris on runway 9L due to a tire malfunction. I responded and requested permission to enter the movement area. Upon obtaining ATC ground clearance; I repositioned to taxiway connector B3 holding short of runway 9L. The tower controller then cleared me to inspect runway 9L and directed me to hold short of intersecting runway 13. I acknowledged the clearance. I proceeded onto runway 9L wbound; commencing from the centerline in a shallow 'south' pattern to cover as much area as possible in night time conditions. At this point I received a radio message on the propriety channel confirming that there indeed had been a main tire 'blowout.' shortly thereafter; during the inspection; I was advised by the tower controller that I had crossed runway 13. I exited runway 9L on taxiway east; holding short of runway 13 on taxiway C facing east. The fll tower controller then asked 'what are your intentions?' I responded by request to inspect runway 9L eastbound. ATC cleared me to cross runway 13 and reinspect runway 9L. I crossed runway 13 and inspected runway 9L. I exited runway 9L at taxiway Q. I then called the ground control; and spoke to the tower supervisor to confirm that an unauthorized movement across an active runway had indeed transpired. Contributing factors: 1) vehicle operator fixated on accomplishing tasks (tunnel vision) during an incident/emergency. Also; limited personnel staffing resources by airport operator. 2) inspecting runway environment area in dark (very limited illumination) trying to find small tire debris. 3) procedural change was made by ATC/tower from ones normally used. This was the first time a clearance to inspect a main runway 9L was issued where a restr to hold short for the intersecting runway (13-31). Normally the entire runway is cleared for inspection. 4) limited visual cues. Hold short signs at intxns at least 500 ft (apart) positioned along runway safety area. 5) runway intersection hold position signs angled away from centerline and vehicle operator. 6) activation of an intersecting and secondary runway without prior inspection by operations personnel. (Potential hazard) corrective actions: 1) vehicle operator: situational/geographical/clearance awareness. Prioritize tasks to comply with directives. 2) vehicle installed GPS advisory location maps and warning device. 3) better awareness of human factors/issues by ATC (ground/tower). Personnel should monitor movements more closely; especially during alert incidents and be cognizant that confusing or non habitual clrncs/directives or communications may hamper working conditions for ground personnel. 4) in pavement guard lights; in pavement hold short lights; etc. 5) increase airport operator personnel staffing. 6) standardized alternate runway operations protocol during incidents. 7) periodic runway incursion assessment meetings for operations; ATC and airline departments.
Original NASA ASRS Text
Title: FLL WORKER REPORTS RUNWAY INCURSION ON TO RUNWAY 13 WHILE INSPECTING RUNWAY 9L FOR TIRE DEBRIS AT NIGHT.
Narrative: I WAS ON DUTY AS RAMP 1; AND RECEIVED A CALL ON THE COMPANY CELL PHONE FROM THE FLL TWR OF POSSIBLE DEBRIS ON RWY 9L DUE TO A TIRE MALFUNCTION. I RESPONDED AND REQUESTED PERMISSION TO ENTER THE MOVEMENT AREA. UPON OBTAINING ATC GND CLRNC; I REPOSITIONED TO TXWY CONNECTOR B3 HOLDING SHORT OF RWY 9L. THE TWR CTLR THEN CLRED ME TO INSPECT RWY 9L AND DIRECTED ME TO HOLD SHORT OF INTERSECTING RWY 13. I ACKNOWLEDGED THE CLRNC. I PROCEEDED ONTO RWY 9L WBOUND; COMMENCING FROM THE CTRLINE IN A SHALLOW 'S' PATTERN TO COVER AS MUCH AREA AS POSSIBLE IN NIGHT TIME CONDITIONS. AT THIS POINT I RECEIVED A RADIO MESSAGE ON THE PROPRIETY CHANNEL CONFIRMING THAT THERE INDEED HAD BEEN A MAIN TIRE 'BLOWOUT.' SHORTLY THEREAFTER; DURING THE INSPECTION; I WAS ADVISED BY THE TWR CTLR THAT I HAD CROSSED RWY 13. I EXITED RWY 9L ON TXWY E; HOLDING SHORT OF RWY 13 ON TXWY C FACING E. THE FLL TWR CTLR THEN ASKED 'WHAT ARE YOUR INTENTIONS?' I RESPONDED BY REQUEST TO INSPECT RWY 9L EBOUND. ATC CLRED ME TO CROSS RWY 13 AND REINSPECT RWY 9L. I CROSSED RWY 13 AND INSPECTED RWY 9L. I EXITED RWY 9L AT TXWY Q. I THEN CALLED THE GND CTL; AND SPOKE TO THE TWR SUPVR TO CONFIRM THAT AN UNAUTH MOVEMENT ACROSS AN ACTIVE RWY HAD INDEED TRANSPIRED. CONTRIBUTING FACTORS: 1) VEHICLE OPERATOR FIXATED ON ACCOMPLISHING TASKS (TUNNEL VISION) DURING AN INCIDENT/EMER. ALSO; LIMITED PERSONNEL STAFFING RESOURCES BY ARPT OPERATOR. 2) INSPECTING RWY ENVIRONMENT AREA IN DARK (VERY LIMITED ILLUMINATION) TRYING TO FIND SMALL TIRE DEBRIS. 3) PROCEDURAL CHANGE WAS MADE BY ATC/TWR FROM ONES NORMALLY USED. THIS WAS THE FIRST TIME A CLRNC TO INSPECT A MAIN RWY 9L WAS ISSUED WHERE A RESTR TO HOLD SHORT FOR THE INTERSECTING RWY (13-31). NORMALLY THE ENTIRE RWY IS CLRED FOR INSPECTION. 4) LIMITED VISUAL CUES. HOLD SHORT SIGNS AT INTXNS AT LEAST 500 FT (APART) POSITIONED ALONG RWY SAFETY AREA. 5) RWY INTXN HOLD POS SIGNS ANGLED AWAY FROM CTRLINE AND VEHICLE OPERATOR. 6) ACTIVATION OF AN INTERSECTING AND SECONDARY RWY WITHOUT PRIOR INSPECTION BY OPS PERSONNEL. (POTENTIAL HAZARD) CORRECTIVE ACTIONS: 1) VEHICLE OPERATOR: SITUATIONAL/GEOGRAPHICAL/CLRNC AWARENESS. PRIORITIZE TASKS TO COMPLY WITH DIRECTIVES. 2) VEHICLE INSTALLED GPS ADVISORY LOCATION MAPS AND WARNING DEVICE. 3) BETTER AWARENESS OF HUMAN FACTORS/ISSUES BY ATC (GND/TWR). PERSONNEL SHOULD MONITOR MOVEMENTS MORE CLOSELY; ESPECIALLY DURING ALERT INCIDENTS AND BE COGNIZANT THAT CONFUSING OR NON HABITUAL CLRNCS/DIRECTIVES OR COMS MAY HAMPER WORKING CONDITIONS FOR GND PERSONNEL. 4) IN PAVEMENT GUARD LIGHTS; IN PAVEMENT HOLD SHORT LIGHTS; ETC. 5) INCREASE ARPT OPERATOR PERSONNEL STAFFING. 6) STANDARDIZED ALTERNATE RWY OPS PROTOCOL DURING INCIDENTS. 7) PERIODIC RWY INCURSION ASSESSMENT MEETINGS FOR OPS; ATC AND AIRLINE DEPTS.
Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site as of May 2009 and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.