Narrative:

ATC gave us traffic advisory, then frequency change. He called back to have us keep on frequency because of proximity of traffic. We saw what appeared to be the aircraft in question (low wing, single engine) at our 11:30 position moving from left to right and appearing to be climbing. ATC instructed us to turn right and climb, which appeared to me to put us on a collision course. Instead I turned left and descended and aircraft passed overhead. We told controller we were clear of traffic and he handled us off to next controller. We had to make turns and altitude changes contrary to controller's discretion. In fact, opp altitude deviations were 500-1000', first climbing, then descending to avoid traffic.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: ACR TOOK EVASIVE ACTION TO AVOID AN SMA IN CLOSE PROX.

Narrative: ATC GAVE US TFC ADVISORY, THEN FREQ CHANGE. HE CALLED BACK TO HAVE US KEEP ON FREQ BECAUSE OF PROX OF TFC. WE SAW WHAT APPEARED TO BE THE ACFT IN QUESTION (LOW WING, SINGLE ENG) AT OUR 11:30 POS MOVING FROM LEFT TO RIGHT AND APPEARING TO BE CLBING. ATC INSTRUCTED US TO TURN RIGHT AND CLB, WHICH APPEARED TO ME TO PUT US ON A COLLISION COURSE. INSTEAD I TURNED LEFT AND DSNDED AND ACFT PASSED OVERHEAD. WE TOLD CTLR WE WERE CLR OF TFC AND HE HANDLED US OFF TO NEXT CTLR. WE HAD TO MAKE TURNS AND ALT CHANGES CONTRARY TO CTLR'S DISCRETION. IN FACT, OPP ALT DEVIATIONS WERE 500-1000', FIRST CLBING, THEN DSNDING TO AVOID TFC.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site as of August 2007 and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.