Narrative:

Right engine spar valve light illuminated along with associated EICAS message. Consulted QRH and found no helpful information. We had a pilot from another airline in the jump seat who showed us his flight handbook; which warned that engine flameout could occur. We got a phone patch with dispatch and maintenance. Maintenance had no helpful guidance and said they found nothing to prevent us from continuing to our destination. We elected to declare an emergency and return to [the departure airport] for an overweight landing. Once again; the jump seating pilot's flight manual provided significantly more information regarding the overweight landing.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: A B757 caution light and EICAS alerted 'engine spar valve' at cruise; so an emergency was declared and the flight returned to the departure airport. The air carrier's QRH contained no guidance about the alert; but a jump seating pilot's QRH cautioned about a possible engine shutdown.

Narrative: Right engine spar valve light illuminated along with associated EICAS message. Consulted QRH and found no helpful information. We had a pilot from another airline in the jump seat who showed us his Flight Handbook; which warned that engine flameout could occur. We got a phone patch with Dispatch and Maintenance. Maintenance had no helpful guidance and said they found nothing to prevent us from continuing to our destination. We elected to declare an emergency and return to [the departure airport] for an overweight landing. Once again; the jump seating pilot's Flight Manual provided significantly more information regarding the overweight landing.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site as of April 2012 and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.