Narrative:

At approximately XA00, aircraft X was cleared for a visual approach to runway 3 at mhk. The captain announced he had the field in sight approximately 7 mi south of the field. About that time, ZKC warned us of another aircraft in the area. After locating the aircraft, we began a descent for the airport. It was at this time that I saw the field as well. The runway ahead that I saw had the same direction runway that we were looking for. During the descent, the GS also came alive. At this time, I was going through the descent and landing checklist, watching aircraft speed, and GS. Upon landing, the captain said we were not at the right airport. The captain notified ATC. ATC then gave us a takeoff clearance from runway 5. We took off and landed at mhk. According to ground handlers at mhk, this is a very common occurrence. In my opinion, if we had approached the airport from any other direction, this would not have happened. When approaching from the south, at a low altitude, you cannot see mhk sitting behind fort riley. It is also not depicted very well on the approach plate. Also since we were receiving GS information, the airport straight ahead, heading the direction expected was a logical choice.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: SW4 CREW LANDED AT MIL FIELD FRI WHEN THEY INTENDED TO LAND AT MHK.

Narrative: AT APPROX XA00, ACFT X WAS CLRED FOR A VISUAL APCH TO RWY 3 AT MHK. THE CAPT ANNOUNCED HE HAD THE FIELD IN SIGHT APPROX 7 MI S OF THE FIELD. ABOUT THAT TIME, ZKC WARNED US OF ANOTHER ACFT IN THE AREA. AFTER LOCATING THE ACFT, WE BEGAN A DSCNT FOR THE ARPT. IT WAS AT THIS TIME THAT I SAW THE FIELD AS WELL. THE RWY AHEAD THAT I SAW HAD THE SAME DIRECTION RWY THAT WE WERE LOOKING FOR. DURING THE DSCNT, THE GS ALSO CAME ALIVE. AT THIS TIME, I WAS GOING THROUGH THE DSCNT AND LNDG CHKLIST, WATCHING ACFT SPD, AND GS. UPON LNDG, THE CAPT SAID WE WERE NOT AT THE RIGHT ARPT. THE CAPT NOTIFIED ATC. ATC THEN GAVE US A TKOF CLRNC FROM RWY 5. WE TOOK OFF AND LANDED AT MHK. ACCORDING TO GND HANDLERS AT MHK, THIS IS A VERY COMMON OCCURRENCE. IN MY OPINION, IF WE HAD APCHED THE ARPT FROM ANY OTHER DIRECTION, THIS WOULD NOT HAVE HAPPENED. WHEN APCHING FROM THE S, AT A LOW ALT, YOU CANNOT SEE MHK SITTING BEHIND FORT RILEY. IT IS ALSO NOT DEPICTED VERY WELL ON THE APCH PLATE. ALSO SINCE WE WERE RECEIVING GS INFO, THE ARPT STRAIGHT AHEAD, HDG THE DIRECTION EXPECTED WAS A LOGICAL CHOICE.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site as of July 2007 and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.